Weld Blog

Compare

Choosing a welding process: MIG, TIG, stick or flux-core

All four processes melt metal with an electric arc. They differ in how they protect the molten puddle from the air, how much you control by hand, and where they work well.

The four processes side by side

This table comes from the same data that draws the bead cards on the home page. It describes how each process works, so you can match it to your projects.

FeatureMIGFlux-coreStickTIG
AWS nameGMAWFCAWSMAWGTAW
What melts inSolid wire fed from a spool by the gunHollow wire with flux inside, fed from a spoolFlux-coated rod held in a clampTungsten that does not melt, plus a filler rod fed by hand
ShieldingBottled shielding gasFlux in the wire (self-shielded types need no gas)The coating burns into gas and slagBottled argon
CurrentDC, electrode positiveUsually DC, electrode negative for self-shielded wireAC or DC, depending on the rodDC for steel, AC for aluminum
SlagNoneThin layer to chip offHeavy layer to chip offNone
In windPoor: a breeze blows the gas awayGood: the flux makes its own shieldGood: the coating makes its own shieldPoor: needs still air
LearningQuick to learn the basicsQuick to learn, messier to finishTakes practice to strike and hold an arcSlowest to learn: both hands and often a foot pedal
Good fit forClean indoor work on steel from thin sheet upOutdoor repairs and thicker steel on small machinesThick, rusty or outdoor steel with simple gearThin metal, stainless, aluminum and neat visible welds

The one idea that explains the differences

Molten steel reacts with oxygen and nitrogen in the air. Left unprotected, the weld fills with tiny holes (porosity) and turns brittle. Every arc process solves this with a shield, and the shield sets most of the trade-offs.

  • Bottled gas (MIG and TIG) makes clean welds with no slag, but a breeze can blow the gas away. These processes suit a garage or shop with the door mostly closed and a fan aimed away from the arc.
  • Flux (stick and flux-core) melts into a gas cloud and a crust of slag that covers the bead as it cools. It shrugs off wind, at the cost of chipping and more spatter to clean up.

Questions that decide it

  1. What will you weld most? Mild steel from thin sheet to about 1/4 inch covers most home and farm work, and MIG or flux-core handles it well. Thin stainless and aluminum point toward TIG.
  2. Inside or outside? If you weld fences, trailers or equipment outdoors, stick or self-shielded flux-core keeps working in a breeze.
  3. How clean is the metal? Stick tolerates rust and mill scale better than the others. TIG needs the cleanest metal of all.
  4. What power do you have? Small machines run on a standard household outlet, and larger ones need a dedicated 240-volt circuit. The machine's manual lists its input power and its duty cycle.
  5. How much time will you put into learning? MIG and flux-core give usable welds quickly. Stick and TIG reward more practice hours.

A note on duty cycle

Duty cycle is how long a machine can weld at a given output within a 10-minute period before it needs to cool. A 30 percent duty cycle at a certain amperage means about 3 minutes of welding and 7 of rest at that setting. Turn the output down and the duty cycle goes up. Beginners rarely hit the limit, because practice welds are short, but it matters for long seams. The rating is printed on the machine and in its manual.

Machines that do more than one

Many small MIG machines also run self-shielded flux-core wire, which usually means swapping the drive rolls and flipping the polarity. Some machines combine MIG, stick and DC TIG in one box. Read the manual for how to switch, since a wrong polarity setting leads to poor welds and heavy spatter.

Where most people start

A common path is MIG or flux-core on mild steel, then stick for outdoor repair work, then TIG once the basics of puddle control feel natural. There is no wrong order. Whatever you choose, the skills carry over: reading the puddle, holding a steady angle and travel speed, and preparing clean, well-fitted joints. Read the full explainers for MIG, flux-core, stick and TIG.

Comparison questions

Which process makes the strongest weld?

Any of the four can make a weld as strong as the base metal when the filler is right for the job and the joint is fused properly. Strength comes down to the operator, the joint design and the filler, more than the process name.

Is flux-core the same as MIG?

They share the same type of gun and wire feeder. MIG uses solid wire and bottled gas. Flux-core uses a hollow wire filled with flux, and self-shielded types need no gas at all.